Monday, July 14, 2008

John 8: Part 2

We are evaluating the inclusion of the adulterous woman episode in John 8. The main issue that must be resolved in determining the authority of the episode is whether or not this story is part of the original text that was inspired by God.

If the self-disclosure of God is contained in the Bible, then to ignore the words of Scripture is equivalent to ignoring God. But to say, "Thus saith the Lord," when God didn't say it, is taking His name in vain, a practice which is tragically too frequent various churches and is equally offensive as ignoring Him. This is one of the "big ten" rules that we're not supposed to break (it's number three).

Most theologians (i.e. the theologians who go by their initials) consider the event to be a true event in the ministry of Jesus. In fact, Stephen Harris, a fellow of the Jesus Seminar (a group of college professors who got together to vote over which sayings of Jesus could be attributed to the Jesus they considered "historical") says, "Whether this episode belongs in John or not, it is consistent with Jesus’ nonjudgmental attitude toward individual ‘sinners’ in all four Gospels” (Harris, Stephen. The New Testament, p. 180). Harris seems okay with the text because it promotes something he wants Jesus to be, "nonjudgmental." However, we don't have the luxury (or perhaps the audacity) of voting on which texts are authoritative and which are not. It would be a better practice to simply reject the Scripture as authoritative at all, rather than picking those teachings that we like best (I realize that people do this practically all the time, but that does not mean it is a good practice and we all could stand to repent on this one).

Determining whether or not the episode took place in the life of Jesus is superfluous and is not the issue. John tells us at the end of his account that, "There are many other things that Jesus did. Were every one of them to be written, I suppose that the world itself could not contain the books that would be written" (John 21:25).

If the episode was not in the original text, then it cannot be said to be Inspired by God and it is not useful for preaching and teaching as a source of authority. It should be demoted from the text into a footnote or removed entirely.

In the next post, we will take a look at the arguments against including the adulterous woman episode and whether or not they are strong enough to constitute removing it from the text and we'll look at the arguments for inclusion....

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

John 8: The Issues

At Missio, we believe that the Bible (the 66 books comprising the Old and New Testament) were verbally inspired in their original languages. While some teach that God was directly involved in the translation of these copies into English (i.e. the King James Version), we do not. But we believe that the texts, in their original form are inspired by God and seek translations that preserve the original form.

Thus, John 8 presents a big question. If you have a copy that is worth reading, it will note that the episode involving the adulterous woman brought to Jesus is not found in the most ancient copies of the text. Untold amounts of ink have been spilled speculating on this issue and because it directly effects us in the study of the Gospel according to John, we are looking into this matter.

At Missio Dei, we utilize the English Standard Version (ESV) for teaching and preaching. In the spirit of the NASB, the ESV follows a word-for-word translation of the original languages and in the spirit of the NIV translates it into a readable format. This seems to be a good corrective for the often difficult syntax of the NASB and the idea-for-idea translation of the NIV.

At John 8, the ESV includes in the text, "The earliest manuscripts do not include John 7:53-8:11." This poses a big problem for our view of Scripture and our approach to the text. If it is not an original part of John's Gospel, should we view it as the authoritative word of God?

Many conservative scholars including B.B. Warfield and A.T. Roberston exclude the passage from John, but consider it authoritative. In fact, D.A. Carson (there must be something about writing theology books that allows one to drop his name and go by initials), a scholar whom I lean upon heavily, writes, "Modern English versions are right to rule it off from the rest of the text (NIV) or to relegate it to a footnote (RSV)…. On the other hand, there is little reason for doubting that the event here described occurred” (Carson, D.A. The Gospel According to John, 1991, p. 333).

This approach seems too good to be true and severely untested for my taste. If this is not an original text, then I cannot say with confidence that it is inspired and authoritative. While I respect the work of these men, I do not embrace this approach to the text. And, for those of you in the Missio Dei community, you are aware that I preached from the text and consider it to be authoritative. I will explain further reasons why in a later post....

Thursday, June 26, 2008

A29 Pastor's Retreat

I can't say enough good about our retreat in Vail. The accommodations were superb, the time spent with brothers "in arms" was unbelievably uplifting, and since Shannon and Evangeline came, I got to spend time with my girls.

Probably the biggest lessons I'm taking away from the retreat (though there are too many to recount), are two. They came from Mark Driscoll's talk with us this morning.

1. Bitch less and pray more
2. Be careful who you're shooting at

Monday, June 16, 2008

Is John 8 part of John's Gospel?

In three weeks, after the move into our new building, I will be preaching in the first story of John 8.

Much debate surrounds the inclusion of this text in the English Bible. In the coming days, I will post some thoughts on how we should approach the passage.

Friday, May 16, 2008

Something to Do


If you're looking for something to do, tonight kicks off Downtown After 5 on Lexington Ave. at I240. There is food and drink and free jazz music.

Downtown After 5 is a monthly event sponsored by the Asheville Dowtown Association.

Many of our favorite restaraunt vendors will be on hand as well as a majority of our favorite local microbreweries.

Friday, May 9, 2008

Organic Community


Church planting for Missio Dei is not the development of a Sunday morning worship activity. Rather, it is the development of a community that is shaped by the Gospel of Jesus Christ. As such, we've been doing a considerable amount of praying and reading on the development of community.

In a very short time and in many ways, I've witnessed tremendous failure and moderate victory as God uses me to develop a gospel-centered community. But I am always looking for refinement and growth. This lead me to read the book Organic Community by Joseph Myers.

Overall, some very helpful questions were asked, but as is often the case in the "Emergent Village," when conclusions are made, they are often over-reactionary in nature. This treatment is no exception.

Myers has an either/or attitude that comes across as arrogant and downright untrue. He presents several false dichotomies in an attempt to welcome a new way of thinking.

While there were several helpful tools that I was able to pull from the book, I'd like to see a more synthesized approach to community. One that doesn't guarantee success if you follow certain prescribed methods, nor look at suspiciously every method prescribed as if it were evil and oppressive.

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Tax Rebate and Good Stewardship


I am very disquieted in my soul about the Economic Stimulus rebate the US government is poised to disseminate beginning this week. Most of us (Christians included) are not thinking much beyond "What can I get for myself with this free money," and that troubles me.

I recognize that the purpose of the rebate is to give a boost to the economy by encouraging spending. Perhaps this will work, but perhaps not. If I decide to put the money in a savings account, am I giving to Caesar what he requires?

Yet, if I give to Caesar, and I put the money into the economy by spending on, say, a flat screen tv, am I giving to God what is God's?

Perhaps, the most Gospel oriented thing we can do is to buy something for another's sake and not be selfish and greedy, like we are most of the rest of the time. Or is there enough Gospel pictured by making an offering with the money and spending a portion giving thanks to God for the bountiful provision?

Thoughts?